The showdown between Makita vs Porter Cable is one we’ve anticipated for a while now. In this in-depth article, you’ll learn all you need to know to make the most informed buying decision. Time to learn!
Table of Contents
- Company Histories
- Makita & Porter Cable Parent Companies
- Product Line Depths
- Brand Reputation & Cost of Tools
- Warranty Comparisons
- Top Combo Kits From Makita & Porter Cable
- Brushless tools: Makita vs Porter Cable
- What about non-brushless?
- What’s the Bottom Line: Makita vs Porter Cable
- Frequently Asked Questions
Makita Company History
For decades now, Makita has been establishing itself as one of the true leaders in the power tool industry. Makita consistently produces some of the best in-class tools on the market, at more than competitive prices.
Currently, as far as cordless drills and impact drivers go (and cordless tools in general), perhaps only Milwaukee is superior in quality and performance than Makita (among all the household names).
Additionally, Makita has consistently been the most innovative brand in the industry.
Porter Cable Company History
Porter Cable was the first to introduce the cordless drill in the 60’s, they perfected the NiCad rechargeable battery in the 70’s, introduced the Li-Ion battery in 2005, and even launched the first line of brushless tools about eight years ago. Quite a track record.
The Porter Cable name, on the other hand, rose to prominence primarily before 1960, when they became renowned as one of America’s finest power tool manufacturers. During the 60’s, the company was bought out by Rockwell Inc. Rockwell caused the quality of Porter Cable tools to decrease as they tried to compete with the ultra-affordable tools being sold in department stores.
Later, though, during the 80’s, they experienced a bit of a resurgence when the Porter-Cable name was acquired by Pentair. Under Pentair they started manufacturing professional-grade power tools again.
Nowadays, Porter Cable (along with DeWalt) is owned by Stanley. Black and Decker, and Porter Cable tools are kind of regarded as an intermediate between consumer and professional-level. They have very good prices, decent quality, but are not really up to par with the best in the industry.
Makita & Porter Cable Parent Companies
Makita is just Makita. It’s one of the few remaining power tool brands that is not owned by a larger company. Makita did acquire the Dolmar brand, increasing its already-impressive line of outdoor power tools.
Stanley Black & Decker (SBD)
Stanley Black & Decker, also known as SBD, is the parent company of Porter Cable. They own a wide variety of brands:
- Black + Decker
Product Line Depths
Both Makita and Porter Cable sell a wide variety of products. Below, you’ll find what each brand’s product line consists of.
Makita Product Line
Makita sells corded, cordless, and gas-powered products. While they may not sell as many products as DeWalt that doesn’t mean they won’t have what you need. For the average consumer, you can find everything that you need.
Here are some of the specific types of products you can purchase from Makita:
- Hedge Trimmers
- Lawn Mowers
- Pole Saws
- Circular Saws
- Miter Saws
- Metal Cutting Saws
- Hammer Drills
- Impact Wrenches
- Area Work Lights
- Random Orbit Sanders
- & More
Porter Cable Product Lines
Porter Cable sells power tools, outdoor power equipment, lighting, generators, storage, hand tools, batteries, and accessories.
Here are some of the specific types of products you can purchase from Porter Cable:
- Combo Kits
- Hand Tools
- Chop Saws
- Circular Saws
- Reciprocating Saws
- & More
Brand Reputation & Cost of Tools
Here we’ll go over the reputations and cost of the tools of each brand.
Makita Reputation and Tool Affordability
This company has received some high praise due to the performance and high quality of the tools they make. Makita tools are truly durable, long-lasting, and tough.
Unlike a lot of other brands, Makita uses high-quality raw materials for its products and holds itself to high manufacturing standards as well. You can literally drop these tools on the ground over and over again, and they’d still work like the day you first bought them.
Consumers have found that Makita tools last a long time; the electrical components, motors, and other components can withstand high amounts of heat, friction, and general wear. It’s also noted how Makita tools are usually comfortable to use, functional, and have a variety of features too.
Overall, Makita tools are viewed as some of the best tools you can buy. Makita tools are great for DIY jobs, crafts, home use, and more. However, Makita products are marketed towards tradesmen, professionals, and anyone else who needs reliable, high-quality tools for daily, heavy-duty use.
The quality you get with these tools does come at a cost. Makita is one of the pricier brands. However, you really do get what you pay for.
Porter Cable Reputation and Tool Affordability
Porter-Cable is the less expensive option of the two brands. This is why so many homeowners and DIYers love their products. Porter-Cable tools are seen as functional, comfortable, and lightweight. However, product durability and longevity are limited.
In other words, Porter-Cable tools are great for those who will be using the tools occasionally, completing DIY jobs, and light home repairs. However, these tools are not ideal for professionals or those completing heavy-duty projects.
Porter-Cable tools are made in Mexico and China, which partially explains the entry-level to mid-level quality.
Makita offers really good warranties on its products. They have a 30-day replacement guarantee on all of their products. Additionally, all tools have at least a one-year general product warranty for defects. Also, all gas=powered tools have a two-year warranty, and all lithium-ion tools come with a three-year limited warranty.
Porter Cable Warranty
Porter Cable, unfortunately, doesn’t have the best warranties out there. The warranties offered by Porter Cable are much more limited. Porter Cable offers mostly a one-year limited warranty. however, some tools come with a three-year limited warranty.
Top Combo Kits From Makita & Porter Cable
Brushless tools: Makita vs Porter Cable
Brushless motors are all the craze nowadays. They offer dramatically improved performance and increased efficiency over brushed motors. (Check out our article on brushless vs. brushed motors here).
However, brushless motors a good deal more expensive too. Porter Cable’s new line of 20V brushless drills and impact drivers have raised eyebrows all across the industry, both in terms of performance and price. Let’s take a look and compare them with Makita’s new brushless line, which are generally regarded as second-best in the industry, behind only Milwaukee’s M18 brushless line.
Porter-Cable 20V Max Li-Ion Brushless Cordless Drill/Impact Driver Combo
The Porter Cable brushless drill/impact driver comes with:
- 2 batteries (2.0 Ah)
- ½” drill and ¼” impact driver
With specs like 3.2 and 2.9 lbs (drill and impact driver, respectively) and 1,400 in lbs of torque (driver), it’s no wonder that these tools are raising eyebrows everywhere.
Yet, do they perform as well as Makita’s new brushless line? Well, not quite. There is still a distinguishable gap in performance.
The price tag is seriously hard to ignore though. Let’s have a look at the Makita and see what we’re dealing with there.
Makita 18V LXT Sub-Compact Brushless Cordless Drill/Impact Driver Combo
This combo comes with the same stuff as the Porter Cable:
- 2 batteries (2.0 Ah)
- ½” drill and ¼” impact driver
The first thing to notice is the difference in battery size between Makita vs Porter Cable. Both come with compact batteries, but the 1.3 Ah Porter Cable batteries are smaller than the 2.0 Ah Makita batteries. And with Makita’s Li-Ion batteries being substantially better quality than PC’s, you’ll notice a pretty drastic difference in performance and charge/run times.
This new Makita line is truly in a class of its own when it comes to compactness. They’ve got nearly double the size battery as the Porter Cable, yet they’re still lighter (2.8 lbs drill, 2.6 lbs driver). Like we said, always expect the absolute best in quality and innovation from Makita.
While the Makita impact driver is spec’d with a slightly less torque (1,240 in lbs) than the Porter Cable, it still performs better. Better designed motor, better engineering, better overall efficiency.
So what about price. The Makita is more expensive, naturally – but only about 18% more expensive. If it were our money, we’d spend more any day of the week and go with the Makita.
Also, if you’re looking for something a little bigger/heavier than the sub-compact line, Makita also has their older model brushless drill/driver kit, with the ½” hammer drill, that is a little less expensive than the newer line. This kit comes with the two 2.0 Ah batteries – if you want to jump up to the larger 4.0 Ah ‘fatpack’ batteries, that’s always an option too.
What about non-brushless?
Not buying into the whole brushless bit, and not ready to spend the extra cash? No worries, all manufacturers are still offering standard brushed motor cordless tools.
Again, for their older ‘brushed’ models, Makita still outperforms the Porter Cable cordless drills and impact drivers, but they cost almost 25% more.
You can get into this 20V cordless drill/impact driver combo from Porter Cable for a decent price.
On the other hand, the competing 18V brushed drill/driver combo from Makita will cost a little bit more. Worth the price difference? Like we said, if it were us, we’d more than willingly spend the extra money to go with Makita. If you don’t plan on getting a lot of use out of the tools, though, then by all means the Porter Cable kits are perfectly fine.
Let’s add another layer to the Makita vs Porter Cable saga.
Where the value of Porter Cable tools really stands out, in our opinion, is in the multi tool combo kits. If you’re just starting out and looking to get your first set of cordless tools, you can get a 6-tool 20V Max combo for a great price.
Included is the following:
- ½” drill
- ¼” impact driver
- reciprocating saw
- circular saw
- oscillating tool
- LED light
- two batteries and a charger
That’s a serious deal!
The same 6-tool kit from Makita, on the other hand, is over 40% more expensive. You could get a huge 8-tool combo from Porter-Cable for less than Makita’s 6-tool. A slight sacrifice in quality, sure, but like we said if it’s your first cordless tool set, a heck of a bargain.
What’s the Bottom Line: Makita vs Porter Cable
Generally speaking, Makita manufactures much better tools than Porter Cable. If we were trying to decide on a tool from one of the two companies, and if money wasn’t a factor, we’d choose Makita all day.
This brings us to a very important consideration, though: price.
Understandably, price is going to be the #1 consideration for most consumers when making a purchase. If you’re shopping for a cordless drill, and you know that the Makita is better than the Porter Cable, you shouldn’t be shunned for going with the Porter Cable if it was, say, 40, 30, or even 20% cheaper.
If you can, definitely go with Makita. You get a significant step up in quality over Porter Cable, at not that huge of a price difference. This goes for both the brushless and brushed tools.
If you’re just starting out and building up your first set of cordless tools, this is where the Porter Cable price value really comes into play. If we were in the market for a six or even eight tool cordless kit, we’d probably prefer to save nearly half the money and go with Porter Cable over Makita
Frequently Asked Questions
Are Makita and Porter Cable the same company?
No, Makita and Porter Cable are not the same company. Makita is owned by just Makita. Porter Cable is owned by Stanley Black & Decker. They own a variety of different brands.
Is Makita good quality?
Makita is often seen as one of the best tool brands that you can purchase today. They offer both brushless and brushed options, and the quality is great for DIYers and home use.
Are Makita tools worth buying?
Some Makita tool tests have found that their tools underperform when compared to other top tool brands. However, Makita offers incredible value for its tools.
Are Porter Cable tools as good as Makita tools?
For the most part, Porter Cable has tools that are less durable than Makita tools. However, there are some that are right on par with the Makita version.
Is Makita better than Porter Cable for cordless hand tools?
There isn’t a direct answer to this question. Makita tools are good quality and perform well. Porter Cable tools are cheaper but can get the job done. However, one is technically better performance-wise. But Porter Cable may be better for you if you’re just performing tasks around the house. Makita makes excellent tools for heavy-duty projects and jobs, but if you don’t need that, why pay the extra money?
Do Porter Cable batteries fit Makita?
Although Porter Cable and Makita are in the same market space, they each have their own accessories, including batteries, to fit their tools. This is how companies ensure customer loyalty.
4 thoughts on “Makita vs Porter Cable Brand Comparison | The Saw Guy”
HI, Russ Thompson. My Mikita impact has routinely defecated on the competition since I purchased it in 2018. DeWalt finally stepped their game up but it took them awhile. THANKS !!!!!
I’m calling BS on this! I’ll put my Porter Cable stuff up against ANY other brand, corded or cordless, ANY day of the week! I do stick with Milwaukee for reciprocating saws though, since, they’re the only ones I’ve ever owned/used.
It’s hard to argue with an overall assessment that Makita tools are better in terms of quality, performance and innovation, even ergonomics. That being said, certain brands have had standout tools in an otherwise so-so line. Porter Cable’s “Tiger Saw” corded reciprocating saw was by far the most powerful of any “known brand”, and was capable of getting through some of the toughest jobs in not time. The saw itself was so powerful and aggressive that even the best blades had a hard time keeping up with what the saw could do. The saw was also a durable tool, albeit not the lightest, but when you really needed to get a tough job done, the Porter Cable “Tiger Saw” came through.
The Porter cable random orbit sanders (*5″ and 6″) were similar in toughness and capability as well, and there were really no competitors, and even after other manufacturers caught up and the passed Porter Cable, the Porter Cable sanders were still reliable, powerful and easy on the wallet.
***The real problem with the various brands of power tools (corded and cordless) is that consumers tend to still think in terms of brand history, when that has long since been meaningless. Old names like DeWalt, Porter Cable, Black & Decker, Skill, Rigid etc. are just labels at this point, after multiple buyouts/brand resurfacings, overseas manufacturing (*sometimes good and sometimes not-so-good). The same holds with Porter Cable today, whereas if you once had a Porter Cable router, you could feel confident you had “the good stuff”, and many stayed in service for decades with periodic service.
As always though, the bottom line is that with any tool, it’s just as important who is holding the tool and the tool itself. The latest and greatest “Star Wars” functionality can help make the job go easier and even sometimes produce a better finished result, but a good solid tool is really what’s important. Even the durability of a tool can depend heavily on not beating the tool up, taking care of the tool and not trying to do things with the tool it was never really intended to handle.
No, Porter Cable tools are not “generally speaking” the best out there now, but they still get the job done in a professional setting. The Porter Cable name though, does not represent what it once did. Makita HAS managed to maintain overall excellent quality, stayed a leader in technology and innovation and kept competitive pricing across their line.
Love porter cable! Wish Lowes would get that craftsman bologna out of its stores and restock with more porter cable again!!